Tag Archives: opinion

Dear Bossip: My Boyfriend Told Me He Has A ‘Bad Habit’ Of Emailing & Texting Women To Hook Up

Dear Bossip , I met him last summer. In a matter of weeks I fell in deep love. He was my first everything. Before him I wasn’t interested in dating or relationships, but I knew I wanted love. Three months in and we’re still good, nice vibes, loving conversations, and walks. I couldn’t believe how much I was into this guy. We made promises to each other to stay faithful and honest. This was no problem for me because I loved him and I would do anything to make it work. Then one day he asked me to send an email from his account to a local council about his parking ticket. No problem of course he’s my baby. I decided to be a bit noisy and look at his inbox and I see a dozen emails from a woman called, “Tosin.”  Browsing through his email it didn’t look too bad until I looked at further emails. It seems like my boyfriend had a girlfriend. Long story short he said it was his ex and they broke up very recently. I was very upset and anxious, but after weeks I brushed it off. Up until December he was still contacting her, and texting her. I was very frustrated and he could tell because my moods weren’t very friendly. Well, then it happened. I emailed her. I took the address from the emails they were sending to each other previously and asked her what was going on. She had no idea that I was a part of his life. She told me that they broke up only in November/December. I was heartbroken. I felt so hurt and used. I broke up with him, but we remained civil along the line. We kept getting together and it was always natural. I couldn’t be upset with him for too long or with anyone. I’m just an easy going person and just so forgiving. But, his ex wasn’t the only problem. He would message girls now and again about meeting up and would continuously get numbers. I would find out, then tell him I’m leaving him, and then he would promise to not do it again saying that they’re bad habits and he’s learning to be a better person. I gave him time to change continuously, but he continues to do the same thing and says he gets carried away and change is happening but it takes time, I love him so much and it’s hard because he’s such a good person, but these habits does weigh down the relationship. He does everything for me and he’s there whenever I need him. If he didn’t have these bad habits he would be the perfect boyfriend for me. But, I’m scared. I don’t want to be hurt again. I feel like my happiness is so attached to him that if we are on bad terms it ruins my day completely. And, I hate that, but I don’t want to feel like I’m missing out on genuine love because I didn’t accept him and didn’t give him time to be a better man. He always talks about how I’m a good girl and how I’m so much calmer and better than his exes. And, he shares his love for me, talks marriage and even kids, but then I get so confused when he messages other girls with flirty texts. And, on top of that the trust I once had for him has really been destroyed. I doubt I can ever rebuild that because I’ve just lost all faith because of the amount of times he’s let me down. I’m more guarded than I was in the beginning. My mother thinks he’s a nice guy, but she doesn’t trust him. She thinks he has other girls. I value her opinion because her doubts about someone or something always seem to be right. She even said that she thinks he had a girlfriend previously which turned out to be true. I don’t know what to do. I’m so confused because he’s a nice guy and I love him. I just don’t want to feel like an idiot. I don’t understand why he messages other women, but gets upset when I want to leave him for it. I don’t want to feel deeply attached if I know he’ll just continue with his bad habits because I don’t want to hurt again. But, I love him. He’s a nice and caring guy. I just don’t feel 100% about the relationship like I did before. Help please. – His Bad Habits Dear Ms. His Bad Habits , Okay, everyone gather your friends and co-workers around your computer, and in your most ratchet turned up hood rat voice I want you to say it with me, “I know he cheat on me, but I love him.” Bwahahahahahaha! You see ladies, this is exactly what happens to you when you lose yourself, and allow a man to consume you. You know longer have an identity. Your language becomes his language. Or, well, you start using his lies as truth because he lies so good to you that you eventually start to believe them. Prime example, he told you that his lying, cheating, and asking women for their numbers to hook up for dates are a “bad habit.” Bwahahahahaha! I can’t! I truly can’t believe he said to you that it’s a “bad habit,” and you believed him. He got a mofo “bad habit” of texting and emailing women to hook up even though he is in a relationship. Bwahahahahaha! I know a lot of men with that “bad habit.” But, you believed him because throughout your letter you have used his language and have said his “bad habit” is basically destroying your relationship, and he needs some time to change (his language) from these so-called “bad habits.” I’m curious why when I read this letter, and observe his behavior that it doesn’t sound like a “bad habit,” it’s more of, hmmm, uhm, oh, I don’t know, HE’S A HOE! He’s a liar. He’s deceptive. He’s a manipulator. He’s a cheater. And, you keep falling for this bull-ish because you have bought into these lies as “bad habits.” A bad habit is leaving the toilet seat up. A bad habit is leaving the television and lights on when you’re not home. A bad habit is biting your nails. A bad habit is throwing your clothes on the floor instead of the laundry basket. How is it a bad habit if he purposely goes online and purposely sends emails to women asking them meet him for a hook up? How is it a bad habit if he purposely hooks up with these women while he’s in a relationship? How is it a bad habit if he purposely goes to meet them, purposely takes off his clothes, and purposely has sex with these women? Bad habit my a**. But, I’ll wait while you ponder this. (Files nails slowly, purses lips, and gives you the side eye). Then, you sit up here and justify his behavior by co-signing his bull-ish as “bad habits,” and that he would be the perfect boyfriend if it weren’t for these “bad habits.” Are you freaking serious? Ma’am, he is trifling. He is full of –ish, and hell naw he ain’t a good boyfriend, or a nice guy. He’s an a**hole. Talkin’ ‘bout he got a “bad habit.” Take your right leg and reach back as far as you can, and kick him in his nuts and tell him you got a bad habit of kicking men in their balls when they lie and cheat. Better yet, take your right hand and reach all the way up to the heavens and swing as hard as you can and smack the dog –ish out of him. Let him know you got a bad habit of smacking the –ish out of men who lie and use bull-ish lies like the ones he’s been feeding you. And, I want you to notice that you said that you would do anything to make it work. Sweetie, that is exactly what YOU’RE doing. You’re doing anything to make it work. You’re trying to make a failed relationship work, and it’s impossible when you’re doing all the damn work. How come he is not doing all that he can to make it work? What about the lie he told you about being committed, faithful, honest, and blah, blah, blah.  I guess he got a bad habit of telling folks what they want to hear when he knows he’s lying. I want you to remember at the top of your letter when you said that you and he made promises to one another to be honest and faithful. Well, he isn’t. He isn’t honest. He isn’t faithful. He is not even remotely interested in making the relationship work. He is not committed to the relationship. HELLO! When people show you who they are believe them. Damn! I’ve said this time and time again. Believe it and them. He’s showing you that he’s not interested in being monogamous. He doesn’t want to be faithful. Walk away! He has a bad habit. So, leave him and his bad habits. LOL! And, please don’t forget that he was dating you and his ex at the same time. That is some low down dirty dog –ish righ there. And, all along he was lying to you and her, and leading you on into believing that he was being faithful to you. Let’s remember that he had a girlfriend the entire time, and that he’d only just recently broke up with her. I bet that was a bad habit of not telling you the truth, huh? But, hold on, if you had not emailed her then your boyfriend would not have told you the truth. (Look in the mirror and see if you have “boo boo the fool” on your forehead). Well, you did say that you are an easy going person, and you keep going back to him. I guess you have a bad habit of doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. I think that’s what they call crazy. Look here, if you don’t respect yourself, and you’re too easy going to be mad at the man who lied to you, deceived you, used you, disrespected you and doesn’t value you, then how can I convince you to leave if you’re too easy going? But, the nail on the head is like what I said earlier that you have lost yourself in this relationship, and have allowed him to consume you. You have no identity. You said in your letter that your happiness is attached to him. Never ever attach your happiness, joy, and being to a man. He cannot make you happy. He can add to your happiness, but it’s not his job to make you happy. And, he cannot bring you joy. He can add to your joy, but it’s not his responsibility to bring you joy. Therefore, when you make another person responsible for your happiness, joy, and other feelings then just know that they will always let you down because no one can fulfill those things. Only you, and only you are responsible for your joy, happiness, and other feelings. You don’t trust him. Leave! He’s not going to change. You women and these hopeful, one day, some day he will be a better man and I want to be there for him to see him through. Uhm, ma’am he is not committed to you. He is committed to his “bad habits.” So, sweetie, while you’re sitting over there confused and stuck on stupid, I want you to pull out your calendar and show me “one day,” and “some day” on the calendar. When you can point them out, then he will one day, some day be the perfect man for you. – Terrance Dean Hey Bossip Fam, what do you think? Share your opinions and thoughts below! Also, e-mail all your questions Terrance Dean : loveandrelationships@bossip.com Follow Terrance Dean on Twitter : @terrancedean “LIKE” Terrance Dean on Facebook , click  HERE! Make sure to order my books Mogul: A Novel (Atria Books – June 2011; $15); Hiding In Hip Hop (Atria Books – June 2008); and Straight From Your Gay Best Friend – The Straight Up Truth About Relationships, Love, And Having A Fabulous Life (Agate/Bolden Books – November 2010; $15). They are available in bookstores everywhere, and on Amazon, click HERE!             

Read the original:
Dear Bossip: My Boyfriend Told Me He Has A ‘Bad Habit’ Of Emailing & Texting Women To Hook Up

Getaway Reviews: Brainless! Inane! Incoherent!

You may wanna turn away right about now, Selena Gomez . The star’s latest movie hits theaters today and let’s just say critics around the country have less than favorable things to say about the thriller, which also features Ethan Hawke and Jon Voight. Just how bad are the reviews? Selena might not want to focus on acting after all. Scroll down for a harsh sampling… Getaway Trailer The action (all at nighttime) is messily and crudely filmed. The plot mechanics are often laughable. – The Associated Press Brainless chase flick doesn’t even offer guilty pleasures. – The Hollywood Reporter So completely idiotic you might swear it was made by Luc Besson and starred Jason Statham or Liam Neeson. – One Guy’s Opinion “Getaway” gets itself embroiled in all sorts of inane situations. Then director Courtney Solomon forgets to give us that basic thrill of all car-chase flicks: watching the car barrel toward its destination. – The New York Daily News The dumbest action movie of the millennium so far. – The Daily Herald It’s meant to be dumb, summer fun. They got the “dumb” part right, and it is summer, but what with the unpleasant characters and inane twists, they forgot to supply the fun. – St. Paul Pioneer Press

Read the rest here:
Getaway Reviews: Brainless! Inane! Incoherent!

Shots Fired: Breezy Disses RihRih On Twitter Again… Says There’s No Love For Someone You Don’t Like!

Breezy and RihRih can’t stop won’t stop with the subliminals. The latest from Breezy is a thinly veiled attack on her inability to be his true friend. Via Hollywood Life reports : Chris Brown went on a Twitter and posted a statement that has left fans betting that he’s talking about nobody else but his ex-girlfriend Rihanna. This is the newest round in an escalating war of words between the once passionate exes. Just 15 days ago, on July 25, Rihanna posted a what looked like a major dig at Chris on her Instagram and now it appears that Chris has responded with an intense message! Chris definitely wants to let his over 12 million fans know exactly why he’s so much happier with Karrueche Tran, than with ex-girlfriend, Rihanna. He posted a very emotional message on Twitter on Aug. 5, filled with question marks, exclamation points and his opinion on what makes a relationship successful. “How do u build a house without a foundation????” Chris tweeted. “Friendship brings the trust and love stronger. You have to like a person to love them!” Wow, this could be one of Chris’ strongest and most heated tweets ever! Is he saying the he has a stronger friendship, trust and love with Karruche, than he ever had with Rihanna? Is he sending Rihanna the message that he loved her but they never built a strong friendship, so they didn’t ‘like’ each other, and that ultimately you must be friends before you’re lovers? There’s really no other way to interpret this. But this is not the first time that Chris and Rihanna have taken their ex-war to Twitter. They’ve been sparring over social media with pointed messages for weeks. Most recently, Rihanna wrote on her Instagram something that might have set Chris off. “I hate when exes say, ‘I’m here if you need me.’ Where the f**k were you when we were together and I needed you?’” This post would definitely send the message to Chris that he wasn’t there when she needed him when they were together. Maybe it was this attack that fueled his feelings that he and Rihanna had a lack of friendship? Rihanna is infamous for posting message about her feelings, for all of her fans to see, because she wants girls to understand that she knows everything they may be going through about heartbreak as well. “She just speaking truth and want other girls to know what time it is and she feels them,” a source tells us. “But it’s all right though, hold ya head up.” SMH… These kids keep acting up. Why do their managers keep lettin’ ‘em?

Read more from the original source:
Shots Fired: Breezy Disses RihRih On Twitter Again… Says There’s No Love For Someone You Don’t Like!

Shots Fired: Breezy Disses RihRih On Twitter Again… Says There’s No Love For Someone You Don’t Like!

Breezy and RihRih can’t stop won’t stop with the subliminals. The latest from Breezy is a thinly veiled attack on her inability to be his true friend. Via Hollywood Life reports : Chris Brown went on a Twitter and posted a statement that has left fans betting that he’s talking about nobody else but his ex-girlfriend Rihanna. This is the newest round in an escalating war of words between the once passionate exes. Just 15 days ago, on July 25, Rihanna posted a what looked like a major dig at Chris on her Instagram and now it appears that Chris has responded with an intense message! Chris definitely wants to let his over 12 million fans know exactly why he’s so much happier with Karrueche Tran, than with ex-girlfriend, Rihanna. He posted a very emotional message on Twitter on Aug. 5, filled with question marks, exclamation points and his opinion on what makes a relationship successful. “How do u build a house without a foundation????” Chris tweeted. “Friendship brings the trust and love stronger. You have to like a person to love them!” Wow, this could be one of Chris’ strongest and most heated tweets ever! Is he saying the he has a stronger friendship, trust and love with Karruche, than he ever had with Rihanna? Is he sending Rihanna the message that he loved her but they never built a strong friendship, so they didn’t ‘like’ each other, and that ultimately you must be friends before you’re lovers? There’s really no other way to interpret this. But this is not the first time that Chris and Rihanna have taken their ex-war to Twitter. They’ve been sparring over social media with pointed messages for weeks. Most recently, Rihanna wrote on her Instagram something that might have set Chris off. “I hate when exes say, ‘I’m here if you need me.’ Where the f**k were you when we were together and I needed you?’” This post would definitely send the message to Chris that he wasn’t there when she needed him when they were together. Maybe it was this attack that fueled his feelings that he and Rihanna had a lack of friendship? Rihanna is infamous for posting message about her feelings, for all of her fans to see, because she wants girls to understand that she knows everything they may be going through about heartbreak as well. “She just speaking truth and want other girls to know what time it is and she feels them,” a source tells us. “But it’s all right though, hold ya head up.” SMH… These kids keep acting up. Why do their managers keep lettin’ ‘em?

Read more from the original source:
Shots Fired: Breezy Disses RihRih On Twitter Again… Says There’s No Love For Someone You Don’t Like!

The CW Reschedules Fall Premieres, Moves Up TVD Opener

The best things come to those who wait… a little less than previously believed. So states The CW in a roundabout way, as the network announced this afternoon a revised fall calendar. It features an earlier premiere date of The Vampire Diaries Season 5 , along with a special Thursday showing of The Originals . Scroll down and plan ahead… The Vampire Diaries Season 5 Preview THURSDAY, OCTOBER 3 8:00-9:00 PM THE VAMPIRE DIARIES (New Season Premiere Date) 9:00-10:00 PM THE ORIGINALS (New Series Premiere Date) MONDAY, OCTOBER 7 8:00-9:00 PM HART OF DIXIE (Season Premiere) 9:00-10:00 PM BEAUTY AND THE BEAST (Season Premiere) TUESDAY, OCTOBER 8 8:00-9:00 PM THE ORIGINALS (Time Period Premiere) 9:00-10:00 PM SUPERNATURAL (New Season Premiere Date) WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 9 8:00-9:00 PM ARROW (Season Premiere) 9:00-10:00 PM THE TOMORROW PEOPLE (Series Premiere) THURSDAY, OCTOBER 10 8:00-9:00 PM THE VAMPIRE DIARIES (Original Episode) 9:00-10:00 PM THE ORIGINALS (Episode 2 Encore) THURSDAY, OCTOBER 17 8:00-9:00 PM THE VAMPIRE DIARIES (Original Episode) 9:00-10:00 PM REIGN (New Series Premiere Date) FRIDAY, OCTOBER 25 8:00-9:00 PM THE CARRIE DIARIES (Season Premiere) 9:00-10:00 PM AMERICA’S NEXT TOP MODEL: GUYS AND GIRLS

See the original post:
The CW Reschedules Fall Premieres, Moves Up TVD Opener

Sharon Osbourne Slams Justin Bieber: You’re Not Black!

Sharon Osbourne is featured in a new interview with The Daily Beast, going off on a number of topics and celebrities. But we have a feeling the opinion that will resonate most loudly with THG readers will Osbourne’s view of Justin Bieber, given the singer’s recent run of scandals and outrageous behavior. “I feel really bad for him,” Osbourne said of the 19-year old. “There’s this little kid with a huge dream, he’s cute, girls love him, and he wants to be a mean boy, and he’s about as mean as a f**kin’ kitten, and he’s trying to act out. “It’s like pissing in a bucket . It’s like, ‘Oh, we’re the bad boys!’ F**k off! You don’t know what bad is.” Sharon went on to label Justin as “lost” and concluded: “I think he doesn’t realize he’s white and not black, that’s a huge problem. And, at the point he’s at in his career, it’s so dangerous because we’ve seen it all before a million times. Where do you go when you’re a child entertainer and then you want to transition to be a man? Very few make it.” Let’s all hope The Biebs is among the minority in that case. Among Osbourne’s many other viewpoints: On the Anthony Wiener penis scandal: “I’d like to slap him. You’re a grown man with a great education, and you think, in this day and age, you can send pictures of your penis over the Internet and not get caught?” On Kanye West: “I have no time for him. He bores me. I said it on the show, he’s an average-looking man with an average talent, but he’s a great salesman. He should sell cars because they would f**kin’ fly out the door.” Osbourne is also a huge fan of Barbara Walters , labeling her an “amazing woman,” of Taylor Swift (she’s “brilliant”) and Justin Timberlake (“the best all-around”). Visit The Daily Beast now for the full Q&A with Osbourne and sound off: Do you think Justin Bieber will make it?

Go here to see the original:
Sharon Osbourne Slams Justin Bieber: You’re Not Black!

Justice For Trayvon: Actor Columbus Short Pens Letter Addressing The Trayvon Martin Case And Race In America

We’re glad to see more celebrities step up for Trayvon . Actor Columbus Short Speaks Out On The Trayvon Martin Case And Race The George Zimmerman verdict made many citizens, especially African Americans feel hopeless and frustrated. Columbus is one of the latest celebrities to voice his opinion on the Trayvon Martin case. A Letter to the Broken Hearted As I have sat and listened to debate after debate, in depth analysis and tempered opinions on “The Verdict” I couldn’t help but feel helpless, frustrated, hurt and yes, angry. As I plummet into the labyrinth of my mind in search of answers, solutions, or a way I could help subdue the burning desire for things to change, my only recourse was to start writing. Presume we step back and take pause for a moment. Pause to take a cultural and personal inventory on where we have come as a people. As oppose to being blinded by the present emotional and economical condition of our nation, our community. What if we begin by acknowledging some of the triumphs, rather than becoming consumed solely by the injustice? I ask these questions for one reason being, that if I reflect and remember just how far we’ve come, instead of sitting and stewing over what has happened, I am now ensuring that I am not going to allow this “Decision” to stifle me as a human being nor as a black man in America. It may seem quite pretentious and easy to hear coming from my heart. However, I assure you I experience the same profiling and discrimination daily regardless of what I happen to do for a living. We must recognize that if we allow this particular ‘lost battle’ in the continuing war, that is ‘Race In America,’ to take us backwards, we will be backtracking and negating the progress that we have already made to date. Hit the flip to read the rest of his letter.

Visit link:
Justice For Trayvon: Actor Columbus Short Pens Letter Addressing The Trayvon Martin Case And Race In America

Mary-Louise Parker May Quit Acting Over "Mean-Spirited" Internet Users

Mary-Louise Parker has nearly had it with the blogosphere. The former Weeds star – who will next be seen in Red 2 and R.I.P.D . – told News Corp Australia that she’s “really not into” acting anymore due to the endless stream of hatred on the Internet. “The world has gotten too mean for me, it’s just too b—-y,” Parker said . “All the websites and all the blogging and all the people giving their opinion and their hatred … it’s all so mean-spirited, it’s all so critical.” Parker isn’t sure what inspires these users, but she can theorize. “It’s sport for people,” she said. “It’s fun to get on at night and unleash their own self-loathing by attacking someone else who they think has a happier life – or something.” The actress (who looks REALLY good naked ) said she tries to stay away from the comments or to brush them off, but it’s difficult. “You have no idea until it happens to you. It doesn’t feel nice,” she said. “I stay away from it as best I can because I’m too thin-skinned, but still it finds you.” And if Parker does drop out of the business? What might she do? “I would write still. I write for Esquire and writing makes me happy. I would take care of my kids and my goats. That’s about it. Bake. Throw my Internet in the lake.”

Follow this link:
Mary-Louise Parker May Quit Acting Over "Mean-Spirited" Internet Users

It’s The Roc: Jay-Z Stops By The Angie Martinez Show, Talks Damon Dash And Miley Cyrus’ Twerking

Jay-Z still got love for Damon Dash. Jay-Z Talks Damon Dash And Miley Cyrus Jay-Z stopped by the Angie Martinez Show to give his opinion on everything from Damon Dash listening to his music to Miley Cyrus’ twerking. Check out the interview below. According to SOHH “Yeah, yeah, yeah,” Jay said when asked about Dash co-signing his new LP. “The thing, what we built, you can’t take that away so no matter what, no time or space — the love is still there. Because what we’ve done will forever be stamped in history. We created something that’s gonna go down forever. So I can only have love for Dame. I just don’t know where we are in our life, we’re not the same two men at that time when we gelled in that way. We were two different people. I haven’t seen him in a while. … [His publicized woes?] I can’t control everything. I can’t control the things in life. Of course if you see somebody going through problems, I have ultimate confidence in him that he’ll find his way ’cause he’s an amazing and smart guy — he’s a hustler and he’s highly intelligent, so I always root for him and always believe that he’ll find his way out of it. But I can’t control what happens in life.” “Miley’s serious, I like what she’s doing right now,” Jay said. “She’s fearless, just being herself — I think it’s more reaction from people wanting her to be ‘Hannah Montana.’ I don’t know, [it’s just from me] watching the situation I would say people want her to be something and she’s like, ‘I’m not that.’ …. That must be really frustrating and this is her reaction to it. Of course it’s loud but it’s understandable. [Miley Cyrus coming to Roc Nation?] Hey, there’s room on the roster. [laughs]“ View the video here If he was stuck on an island would he rather hear Damon Dash talk about his music or see Miley Cyrus twerk? Oh the possibilities.

Read more:
It’s The Roc: Jay-Z Stops By The Angie Martinez Show, Talks Damon Dash And Miley Cyrus’ Twerking

Paula Deen Cites Prop 8 Ruling in Seeking Lawsuit Dismissal

Embattled celebrity chef Paula Deen is using an unusual legal argument to hit back at Lisa Jackson, the former employee suing her for discrimination. Deen’s camp cited the Supreme Court’s June 26 decision striking down California’s Prop 8 as a reason a court should dismiss Jackson’s lawsuit. How does that work, you ask? Lisa Jackson filed a federal complaint against Deen and her brother, Bubba Hiers, for subjecting her to racial harassment and a hostile work environment. Among other things, Jackson alleges that Deen made racist remarks about her employees. Paula denies this, but admits using racial slurs in the past. The Food Network decided not to renew her contract as a result of that admission, and a slew of the famed cook’s sponsors dumped her, as well. Now Deen’s legal team is hitting back hard against Jackson, charging in a brief that one of the plaintiff’s core claims against Paula is a complete lie. Specifically, Deen says Jackson’s claim that she was personally offended by Paula’s utterance of racial slurs since she has biracial nieces is untrue. Her lawyers have cited evidence that Jackson’s nieces are actually those of her partner’s, and that the little girls are Hispanic, not African-American. As such, Deen’s attorneys noted the opinion of the Supreme Court and Chief Justice John Roberts on the Hollingsworth vs. Perry Prop 8 case. In order to have standing to sue, a person must prove they have “suffered a concrete and particularized injury that is fairly traceable to the challenged conduct.” “In other words, for a federal court to have authority under the Constitution to settle a dispute, the party before it must seek a remedy for a personal and tangible harm.” In Deen’s view, given that Jackson is white, she doesn’t have standing to bring the case because she herself didn’t suffer personally from race discrimination. She also lied or at least embellished the alleged discrimination. The court has yet to rule in the case, which has already torpedoed Deen’s empire. You can bet she will fight this tooth and nail, then likely countersue.

More here:
Paula Deen Cites Prop 8 Ruling in Seeking Lawsuit Dismissal